Very nice setting in a resort. Service was good. Food was good.
The place is beautiful. The decor, wood moulding and doors beautiful! Service was excellent. BUT! The prices are heinous for the quality of food. 6 coconut shrimp for $28 that at that price should be freshly coated and fried. These were previously frozen. I got the Mahi sandwich which also not freshly cooked or caught and questionably not even Mahi. The brioche bun was more like a white bread roll from a deli. I knew it was expensive going in. Quality fresh seafood is actually not the easiest to find down here. I can be a bit of a food snob coming from NYC. But in comparison to all the other places in the area...I can't seem to justify those prices with that sort of quality.
We didn't have a reservation, but since the place was empty we took a shot. We were greeted by Bethany the hostess who told us they were booked, but she would squeeze us in. Thank you Bethany, your pretentious attitude made us feel very welcome.
It's a good restaurant but pay attention, or you could get taken.
I also hope Bethany can find a job she is more suited for
Our biggest surprise came when Cheryl brought the check. They are so helpful that they go ahead and add an 18% gratuity to the check for a party of two? Really?
At the adjoining table we discovered, Bethany, who was chatting it up with her parents. It would seem they had no problem finding a table, even at a "booked" restaurant.
Food is exceptional in both quality and presentation. Atmosphere and decor was clean with a southern seaside charm. Only drawback was it is quite pricey. Entrees were priced reasonably, but starters/appetizers were high.
We were seated and Cheryl took good care of us, the food was very good, if a little slow, but hey we are on vacation.
We went there for desserts and TDF was indeed like it's name. Nice ambient and friendly staff.
I didn't even notice until we had left and I looked at the receipt, I just paid the bill and left a 20% tip for Cheryl, so now with the 18% the house added she had a good night.
Butterfly Cafe is a US Cafe based in Marathon, Florida. Butterfly Cafe is located at 2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, USA.
Please contact with Butterfly Cafe using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Butterfly Cafe opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.